Auto dealership set to take over long-abandoned supermarket location in Staten Island.

View pictures in App save up to 80% data.

Island Auto Group has announced that construction will soon commence on a new Toyota sales and service center, which will take the place of the old ShopRite store situated at the intersection of Locust Avenue in New Dorp. Below is an illustration of the upcoming project. (Image provided by Toyota Motors)

STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. -- A significant section of long-unused commercial property on Hylan Boulevard is set to be revitalized, evolving into one of the largest auto dealerships in New York City. Island Auto Group has announced that construction will commence shortly on a 50,000-square-foot Toyota sales and service facility, which will take the place of the former ShopRite store at the intersection of Locust Avenue in New Dorp.

Marcello Sciarrino, co-owner of Island Auto Group, expressed his enthusiasm for the project, stating, “This initiative is thrilling for us, not just because we are constructing the largest sales and service facility for Toyota in the NYC metropolitan area… [but also because] it sets off a chain of other developments for our organization.” He further mentioned, “We are planning to relocate and refurbish several of our nine dealerships on Staten Island to enhance our service to the community.” Island Auto Group is recognized as one of the largest multi-franchise sales and service entities in the Northeast.

Situated at 2424 Hylan Blvd., the upcoming dealership will boast more than 40 service bays for new vehicles and will offer a selection of both new and pre-owned cars. Sciarrino expects that it will generate between 60 to 70 new job opportunities and is set to launch in the spring of 2026.

View pictures in App save up to 80% data.

Situated at 2424 Hylan Blvd., the recently opened dealership will offer more than 40 service bays for new vehicles and will provide a selection of both new and pre-owned cars. (Image provided by Toyota Motors)

“We take great pride in that,” he added. “I believe this is a positive development for the Staten Island community.”

The new site replaces the former ShopRite, which shuttered in 2020 when the supermarket relocated less than a half mile away to The Boulevard shopping center.

Sciarrino mentioned that he has been collaborating with Kimco Realty, the landlord of the site located in Long Island, for several years to secure the property. To obtain the necessary approvals for conducting sales and service operations at the location, he had to submit rezoning applications to the NYC Board of Standards and Appeals (BSA). He expressed confidence that the outcome of these efforts will lead to a well-maintained and serene facility that will be appreciated by the surrounding community.

“According to Sciarrino, ShopRite operated around the clock, seven days a week, catering to approximately 1,500 customers each day. He noted that the new plan will result in a significantly lower density of activity. Additionally, we are committed to enhancing the aesthetics of the area by incorporating plenty of greenery, including plants and shrubs, along with soft LED lighting.”

View pictures in App save up to 80% data.

The newly opened Toyota sales and service center will feature parking space for more than 400 vehicles. (Image provided by Toyota Motors)

According to Sciarrino, the new construction marks the initial phase of a minor transformation for Island Auto Group.

"Sciarrino announced, 'We are expanding our Jeep service department to a new, dedicated service center, increasing our service area from 5,000 square feet to more than 20,000 square feet. This expansion will enable us to add an additional 15 service bays.' He also mentioned that we will be moving our Subaru and Hyundai showroom and sales operations to Hylan Boulevard."

In total, the automotive group is introducing more than 60 service bays for all its brands, creating larger waiting areas and enhancing onsite parking facilities.

“As a proud resident of Staten Island, I feel deeply connected to this community,” Sciarrino stated in closing. “We are thrilled to be growing our business in this way, providing our neighbors with additional sales and service opportunities.”

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.