'Once in a generation' Smithfield scheme in Birmingham takes step forward

What the Birmingham Smithfield development could look like

A 'once in a generation' scheme to transform Birmingham city centre has taken a significant step forward. The city council's planning committee has approved proposals to construct hundreds of homes as part of the huge Smithfield project.

The specific development discussed at the latest planning meeting was a single block of 408 apartments with flexible commercial space, including leisure and wellness facilities and retail units. It will be erected on a plot within the Smithfield masterplan area, which aims to convert the former wholesale markets near the Bullring shopping centre into a new destination featuring residential buildings and cultural spaces.

The vast Smithfield development, whose outline application was approved last year, could also include a park, market, pub/bar, theatre/cinema, retail, office space and more. However, today's planning committee raised concerns about the housing mix and design of the proposed apartment block, which will feature a blend of one, two and three-bedroom flats.

Coun Colin Green expressed his fear that the number of one-bedroom, one-person flats could lead to a "transitory population who don't stick around" and a "lack of community". He said: "I'm conscious the decisions we make today will last for 100 years – this is not a short-term problem," adding, "If we approve this, the mistake to the city will last into the next century."

Coun Martin Brooks expressed his scepticism about the design of the proposed development, stating: "This scheme will last for many years," and "We haven't thought big enough in terms of what we're doing here."

The Birmingham Civic Society has previously voiced similar concerns, particularly criticising the "limited design quality" and a housing unit mix "which does not benefit families". They argued that this "This does not bode well for later elements that will be brought forward,".

However, a council officer reassured the meeting today, stating: "We do consider the scheme aligns with the design code."

Coun Lee Marsham, chair of the planning committee, added that "beauty is in the eye of the beholder".

Addressing concerns over the housing mix, a council officer's report published ahead of the meeting stated that the site only formed a proportion of the units proposed to be delivered across Smithfield. It said: "While this plot has a lower proportion of three bed units, it can be supported in this phase of the masterplan given that the plot falls within the northern part of the wider site, where the focus is on commercial and civic uses," The report further explained that "The predominantly residential area of the site is to the south."

The report also highlighted that the proposed apartments would make a "meaningful contribution" towards Birmingham's housing shortfall and help regenerate part of the city centre. The proposed development was approved, subject to conditions, following a vote among the members of the committee.